Best Golf Balls For Mid Handicapper

Best Golf Balls For Mid Handicapper

By Paul Liberatore

|

Published:

|

Last Updated:

Are you a mid handicapper looking to take your golf game to the next level? One of the most important factors in improving your performance is playing with the right golf ball. With so many options on the market, it can be overwhelming to choose the best one for your skill level. In this comprehensive guide, we'll break down the key characteristics to look for and recommend the top golf balls for mid handicappers in 2024.

What Defines a Mid Handicapper?

Before we dive into the best golf balls, let's clarify what we mean by a "mid handicapper." Generally, golfers with a handicap between 8 and 18 fall into this category. If you typically shoot in the 80s or low 90s, you're likely a mid handicapper. Understanding your skill level is crucial when selecting the right golf ball.

Key Characteristics of Golf Balls for Mid Handicappers

When shopping for golf balls, there are several key factors to consider:

  • Distance and Speed: As a mid-handicapper, you want a ball that provides a good distance off the tee without sacrificing too much control. Look for balls with slightly lower compression, which can help generate more speed and distance with your medium swing speed.
  • Spin and Control: While distance is important, you also need a ball that offers adequate spin and control around the greens. Urethane or ionomer cover layers can provide the right balance of spin and feel for your short game.
  • Feel and Compression: The feel of a golf ball is largely determined by its compression. Mid-handsappers typically benefit from a medium compression ball that offers a softer feel without sacrificing too much distance.
  • Construction: Golf balls come in various constructions, most commonly 2-piece and 3-piece. 2-piece balls are often more durable and provide more distance, while 3-piece balls offer better spin and control. Consider your priorities when deciding between the two.

Top Golf Ball Picks for Mid Handicappers in 2024

Best Feel - Srixon Soft Feel Golf Balls

You're in for a treat with the Srixon Soft Feel golf balls. These balls are engineered to deliver an exceptional blend of distance and soft feel that will elevate your game from tee to green. The secret lies in Srixon's innovative FastLayer Core technology, which transitions from a soft inner core to a firm outer edge. This design optimizes energy transfer for impressive ball speeds and reduces long game side spin, resulting in straighter, longer shots.


The Soft Feel's thin, soft Ionomer cover enhances greenside control and provides a delightfully responsive feel on every shot. You'll appreciate the confidence-inspiring feedback and consistent performance, whether you're hitting a delicate chip or a powerful drive. Srixon's advanced 338 Speed Dimple Pattern further enhances the ball's aerodynamics, promoting a high launch angle and penetrating flight path for maximum carry distance.


Crafted with the needs of a wide range of golfers in mind, the Srixon Soft Feel is a versatile choice that delivers outstanding performance at an affordable price point. Its low-compression core is particularly well-suited for players with slower swing speeds, offering a perfect balance of distance, forgiveness, and soft feel. The ball's unique "hit straight" alignment arrow also aids in promoting target focus and ensuring square setup for improved accuracy on the greens.


With the Srixon Soft Feel, you can trust that you're playing with a high-quality, durable ball that will help you unlock your full potential on the course. Embrace the exceptional feel, distance, and control that these balls provide, and watch your scores drop as you enjoy the game like never before.

Srixon Soft Feel Golf Balls
 

Best for Short Game - Kirkland Signature 3-piece Urethane Cover Golf Balls

The Kirkland Signature 3-piece Urethane Cover Golf Balls have shaken up the golf ball market since their introduction. Costco, known for its bulk wholesale products, entered the golf equipment space with these balls, offering a premium-like product at a fraction of the cost of big-name brands.


These balls feature a three-piece construction with a urethane cover, typically found in high-end golf balls. The core is designed for distance, while the mantle layer helps control spin. The urethane cover provides a soft feel and spin control around the greens.


Golfers have been drawn to these balls due to their performance-to-price ratio. They offer characteristics similar to tour-level balls at about half the cost. This has led to both excitement and controversy in the golf industry.


When first released, the Kirkland balls quickly gained popularity among amateur golfers. Some even claimed they performed as well as top-tier balls from established brands. This led to supply issues as demand outpaced production.


The balls have gone through several iterations since their initial release. Costco has worked to improve performance and consistency while maintaining a low price point. Recent versions have addressed some of the early criticisms regarding durability and off-the-tee performance.


Golf ball manufacturers like Titleist have taken notice of Kirkland's success. There were even legal disputes over patent infringements, which were eventually settled out of court.


While not universally praised by low-handicap players or those with very high swing speeds, the Kirkland balls have found a strong following among mid-to-high handicappers and budget-conscious golfers. They've proven that quality golf balls don't always need a premium price tag.


The success of these balls has sparked discussions about pricing in the golf industry and whether other manufacturers could offer similar value. It's also led to increased interest in direct-to-consumer golf brands.

Kirkland Signature 3-piece Urethane Cover Golf Balls

Best for Distance - Callaway Supersoft Golf Balls

You're gonna love the Callaway Supersoft Golf Balls. These babies are a game-changer for golfers of all skill levels. Let's break it down.


The Supersoft is all about distance, accuracy, and feel. Callaway engineered these balls with a HyperElastic SoftFast Core that cranks up your ball speed off the tee. You'll be bombing drives like a pro.


But here's the kicker - they're not just long, they're straight too. The low-spin design helps keep your shots on target, so you're spending less time hunting for balls in the rough.


Now, let's talk feel. The Supersoft lives up to its name with a super soft touch around the greens. The hybrid cover gives you great control for those delicate chip shots and putts.


Callaway's constantly tweaking the design. The latest version has an improved cover that boosts greenside spin without sacrificing distance. It's like having your cake and eating it too.


These balls come in a bunch of colors, so you can pick your favorite or switch it up for visibility. White, yellow, orange, pink - take your pick.


Price-wise, they're a sweet spot between budget and premium balls. You're getting a lot of tech for your buck.


The Callaway Supersoft is a solid all-rounder. It's forgiving for beginners but still performs for better players. If you're looking for a ball that'll help you hit it longer, straighter, and softer, give these a shot. You might just find your new go-to ball.

Callaway Supersoft Golf Balls

Best for Slow Swings - Wilson Staff Duo Soft Golf Balls

Wilson Staff Duo Soft golf balls have carved out a unique niche in the golf ball market. These balls are known for their incredibly soft feel, making them a favorite among players who prefer a cushioned impact. The Duo Soft boasts a compression rating of just 35, which Wilson claims makes it the softest golf ball in the world.


The ball's core uses Wilson's VelocitiCOR technology, which aims to extract maximum power from your swing. This low-compression core is designed to compress more easily at impact, potentially helping slower swing-speed players achieve greater distances. The soft feel doesn't just apply to full shots - many golfers appreciate the gentle touch these balls provide around the greens and on putts.


Wilson wraps the Duo Soft's core in a Surlyn cover with 302 dimples. This dimple pattern is engineered to provide a stable, penetrating ball flight. While Surlyn covers typically don't offer as much spin control as urethane, they tend to be more durable and cost-effective.


Price-wise, the Duo Soft sits in the budget-friendly category. You can often find these balls for under $25 per dozen, making them an attractive option for golfers looking to balance performance with affordability. Wilson offers the Duo Soft in several color options beyond traditional white, including optic yellow, green, orange, and pink.


Performance-wise, the Duo Soft tends to excel in certain areas while making trade-offs in others. The ultra-soft compression can lead to an excellent feel and potentially more distance for slower swingers. However, faster swing speed players might find they lose some control and spin, particularly on approach shots and around the greens.


Wilson positions the Duo Soft as an all-around performer suitable for a wide range of golfers. However, it's particularly well-suited to players with slower swing speeds, those who struggle with harder-feeling balls, or golfers simply looking for a quality ball at a budget-friendly price point.

Wilson Staff Duo Soft Golf Balls

Best for Maximum Distance - Srixon Q Star Tour Golf Balls

You're gonna love the Srixon Q Star Tour golf balls. These babies are designed for regular golfers like you and me who want tour-level performance without breaking the bank.


The Q Star Tour is Srixon's softest tour-level ball, perfect for players with moderate swing speeds around 75-95 mph. It's got a urethane cover that gives you killer spin and control around the greens, just like the premium balls the pros use.


Under the hood, there's some cool tech going on. The FastLayer Core transitions from soft in the center to firm on the outside, giving you both distance and feel. The Spin Skin coating grabs onto your clubface for even more spin.


On full shots, you'll get a nice high launch with low spin for distance. But around the greens, it bites and stops on a dime. The soft feel is awesome, especially on putts.


Srixon tweaked the latest version to be a bit firmer and faster, while still keeping that soft feel we love. They also updated the dimple pattern to 338 dimples for better flight in the wind.


The best part? You get all this performance at a lower price than the big-name tour balls. Srixon's really gunning for market share with this one.


So if you want tour-level short game control and solid distance without emptying your wallet, give the Q Star Tour a shot. Your game (and your bank account) will thank you.

Srixon Q Star Tour Golf Balls

 

Best Overall - TaylorMade Tour Response Golf Balls

TaylorMade Tour Response golf balls are a game-changer for golfers seeking tour-level performance without breaking the bank. These balls hit the sweet spot between premium and budget options, offering exceptional value for your money.


The Tour Response features a three-piece construction with a cast urethane cover, similar to TaylorMade's premium TP5 and TP5x balls. This cover provides excellent greenside spin and control, allowing you to attack pins with confidence. The ball's 70 compression rating makes it ideal for golfers with moderate swing speeds, offering a soft feel without sacrificing distance.


One of the standout features of the Tour Response is its Tour Flight Dimple Pattern. This design, borrowed from TaylorMade's top-tier balls, optimizes aerodynamics to promote a strong, penetrating ball flight. You'll notice improved carry distances and better performance in windy conditions.


The Tour Response also incorporates a Hi-Spring Core and a SpeedMantle with HFM (High-Flex Material). These technologies work together to maximize energy transfer at impact, resulting in impressive ball speeds across all clubs in your bag.


For golfers who struggle with alignment, TaylorMade offers the Tour Response Stripe version. This unique design features a colored stripe around the ball's equator, providing a clear visual aid for putting and tee shots.


TaylorMade has positioned the Tour Response as a direct competitor to other "value urethane" balls like the Titleist Tour Soft and Callaway Chrome Soft. In terms of performance, many golfers find the Tour Response holds its own against these more expensive options.


While the Tour Response may not offer the exact same level of spin control as TaylorMade's TP5 series, it comes remarkably close. For most amateur golfers, the difference in performance is negligible, making the Tour Response an attractive option for those looking to save some cash without sacrificing quality.

TaylorMade Tour Response Golf Balls

Best for Accuracy - Callaway ERC Soft Triple Track Golf Ball

You're in for a treat with the Callaway ERC Soft Triple Track golf ball. This innovative ball is packed with cutting-edge technology to help you crush it off the tee and stick it close to the pin. The ERC Soft features Callaway's longest golf ball core ever, the High Energy Core, which is designed to maximize ball speed and distance. But don't let the "soft" in the name fool you - this ball still provides exceptional greenside control thanks to its unique hybrid cover.


The real game-changer with the ERC Soft is the Triple Track alignment aid. Callaway borrowed this technology straight from aircraft carriers, using three high-visibility lines to create a foolproof alignment system for your putts. Just line up the ball with your target and watch your accuracy improve dramatically.


Under the hood, the ERC Soft is loaded with proprietary Callaway tech. The High Speed Mantle layer creates efficient energy transfer between the core and cover for explosive ball speed. The soft Paraloid Impact Modifier cover material provides great durability while still offering a soft feel and high spin around the greens.


Whether you're a high handicapper looking for more distance or a single-digit shooter who wants precision control, the Callaway ERC Soft Triple Track delivers. With a compression rating of 60, it's soft enough for slower swing speeds but still offers penetrating ball flight for better players. Simply put, this ball is a total package that can benefit any golfer. If you want to play your best golf in 2024, put the Callaway ERC Soft Triple Track in play.

Callaway ERC Soft Triple Track Golf Balls

Best Quality -Vice Pro Soft Golf Ball

The Vice Pro Soft is a premium golf ball designed for players with swing speeds under 95 mph who demand an exceptionally soft feel without sacrificing performance. This three-piece ball features a cast urethane cover, which is typically found on high-end, tour-level golf balls. The extra-thin cover promotes enhanced feel and increased spin around the greens, allowing you to control your shots with precision.


At the core of the Vice Pro Soft is the High Energy Speed Core (HESC), engineered to maximize ball speed and distance off the tee. Despite its low compression rating of 35, this ball still delivers impressive velocity, making it a great choice for golfers with moderate swing speeds who want to add a few extra yards to their drives.


The Vice Pro Soft also boasts a unique 318 large dimple design, which helps to create a stable, penetrating ball flight. This dimple pattern is particularly beneficial in windy conditions, as it minimizes the effects of crosswinds and helps the ball maintain a straight trajectory.


One of the standout features of the Vice Pro Soft is its matte finish. In fact, it was the first urethane-covered golf ball in the industry to offer this unique coating. The matte finish not only provides a distinctive look but also reduces glare when addressing the ball, allowing you to focus on your target with greater clarity.


With its combination of soft feel, impressive distance, and excellent spin control, the Vice Pro Soft is a top contender in the premium golf ball market. It offers performance that rivals more expensive brands at a fraction of the cost, making it an attractive option for budget-conscious golfers who refuse to compromise on quality.

Vice Pro Soft Golf Balls


Choosing the Right Ball for Your Game

With so many great options available, how do you choose the right ball for your game? Here are a few tips:

  • Assess Your Swing Speed and Ball Flight: Understanding your swing speed and typical ball flight can help narrow down your choices. If you have a slower swing speed, prioritize lower compression balls for more distance. If you tend to hit the ball high, look for balls with lower spin rates.
  • Prioritize Your Needs: Think about what's most important to you in a golf ball. Is it maximum distance off the tee? Superior feel and control around the greens? A balance of both? Prioritize your needs and select a ball that aligns with those priorities.
  • Test Different Options: The best way to find the right ball is to test a few different options on the course. Most golf shops offer sample packs or will allow you to buy individual sleeves of balls to try. Take note of how each ball performs off the tee, on approach shots, and around the greens.
  • Don't Default to Tour Balls: Many mid handicappers assume they should play the same balls as tour professionals, like the Titleist Pro V1. However, these balls are designed for elite swing speeds and may not be the best fit for your game. Stick with balls designed for your skill level.
  • Stick with Your Choice: Once you find a ball that works well for your game, stick with it for consistency. Using the same ball round after round will help you develop a better feel and understanding of how it performs in various situations.

Golf Ball Buying Tips

Here are a few additional tips to keep in mind when purchasing golf balls:

  • Buy in Bulk: If you've found a ball you love, consider buying in bulk to save money in the long run. Many retailers offer discounts when you purchase multiple dozen.
  • Consider a Ball Fitting: If you're serious about optimizing your equipment, consider getting a ball fitting from a professional. They can analyze your swing and recommend the best ball for your unique characteristics.
  • Avoid Mixing Models: It's best to avoid mixing different ball models within your bag. Different balls will have different flight characteristics and feel, which can negatively impact your consistency.
  • Invest in Quality: While it's tempting to always choose the cheapest option, investing in a high-quality ball that suits your game can pay off in terms of performance. Don't be afraid to spend a little more on a ball that will help you play your best.

Conclusion

Choosing the right golf ball is a critical component of playing your best as a mid-handicapper. By understanding the key characteristics to look for and trying out our top recommendations, you'll be well on your way to finding the perfect ball for your game. Remember to prioritize your needs, test different options, and stick with your choice for optimal performance on the course. Here's to lower scores and more enjoyment on the links!

Frequently Asked Questions

What compression should I look for in a golf ball as a mid handicapper?

As a mid handicapper with an average swing speed, you should look for golf balls with medium to low compression, typically in the 70-90 range. Lower compression balls will compress more easily at impact, providing a better feel and potentially more distance. Some good examples are the Srixon Q-Star Tour and Kirkland Signature 3-piece balls.

Do I need a urethane cover golf ball?

Urethane covers provide the highest spin and softest feel around the greens, which many mid-handicappers prefer. However, they also come at a higher price point. If you prioritize short-game control and don't mind spending a bit more, urethane balls like the Wilson Staff Model or Titleist AVX are great options. If you're on a tighter budget, ionomer cover balls can still provide good performance.

Are 2-piece or 3-piece golf balls better for my game?

The choice between 2-piece and 3-piece balls depends on your priorities. 2-piece balls are often more durable and provide more distance off the tee, while 3-piece balls typically offer a better feel and spin around the greens. As a mid handicapper, a 3-piece ball like the Srixon Q-Star Tour or Kirkland Signature can provide a good balance of distance and short game performance.

Should I play the same balls that tour professionals use?

Not necessarily. Tour-level balls like the Titleist Pro V1 are designed for elite swing speeds and may not be the best fit for average mid-handicap swing speeds. You'll likely get better performance from balls designed for your skill level, which have lower compression and are optimized for slower swing speeds. Stick with balls made for mid-handicappers for the best results.

Is it worth getting a ball fitting?

If you're serious about optimizing your equipment and playing your best golf, a ball fitting can be a worthwhile investment. A professional can analyze your swing and ball flight to recommend the ideal ball for your game. While it's not essential, it can help you find the perfect fit and potentially unlock some extra distance or spin. Many golf shops and club fitters now offer ball-fitting services.

Paul Liberatore

Paul Liberatore

As the Founder of Golfers Authority Paul Liberatore Esq. has spent the last 7+ years writing about the best golf equipment or instruction from the top golf instructors in the world. He has been a contributing writer for Sports Illustrated Golf and GolfWRX. After graduating with honors from Purdue University, he realized that he had a passion for the golf business and the law. When he's not practicing law, or creating golf content on YouTube, he can be found on his syndicated Behind the Golf Brand podcast talking with the most prolific leaders in the golf industry.