For the better part of two decades, I have remained a loyal proponent of blade irons. The traditional profile at the address offers an aesthetic appeal that I find indispensable. But when TaylorMade sent over the TP Mullen for testing, I figured I'd give it an honest shot. After all, if Jason Day and Dustin Johnson have trusted their millions to TaylorMade's TP line, who am I to dismiss it without a proper trial?
What struck me immediately was how this doesn't look like your typical mallet. The Mullen has this clean, compact shape that somehow manages to look purposeful without being bulky. It's like TaylorMade took everything intimidating about mallets and stripped it away, leaving just the good stuff. The 303 stainless steel construction gives it a premium feel right out of the headcover, none of that cheap, tinny sensation you get with some modern putters.
Table of Contents
Quick Overview
Premium 303 stainless steel compact mallet with Pure Roll Insert technology featuring 45-degree grooves for immediate topspin and improved distance control.
Performance testing showed putting improvement from 31.2 to 29.8 putts per round and increased make percentage from 62% to 71% between 4-8 feet.
Larger sweet spot from sole weights provides excellent stability on off-center hits while maintaining line and distance.
Simple two-sightline alignment system with milled lines offers clear targeting without visual clutter, boosting confidence at address.
Premium price point may deter casual golfers, and slight toe hang design suits arc strokes better than straight-back-straight-through putting styles.
TaylorMade TP Mullen Putter Review
TaylorMade TP Mullen Putter delivers buttery-soft feel and elite consistency on every putt.
Pure Roll Insert: The Game-Changer Nobody Talks About Enough
Let me tell you about the moment this putter won me over. It was a downhill six-footer at my home course – the kind that usually has me sweating bullets because I tend to hit it too firm and watch it race past. With the Mullen's Pure Roll insert, the ball came off the face with this controlled energy that I hadn't experienced before. The 45-degree grooves grabbed the ball and imparted immediate topspin, killing that annoying skid phase that wreaks havoc on distance control.
The insert uses a softer polymer that provides what I can only describe as "connected feel." You know exactly where you hit it on the face, but it's not harsh. It's like the difference between catching a baseball with a good leather glove versus bare hands; you get all the feedback without the sting. I've rolled this thing on everything from lightning-fast country club greens to the shaggy municipal surfaces I grew up on, and the consistency is extraordinary.
What really sold me was taking it to a putting studio and watching the ball roll on high-speed cameras. The forward roll starts almost immediately off the face. I compared it to my old blade and two other mallets I've tested this year, and the Mullen consistently got the ball rolling 20% sooner. That translates to putts that hold their line better, especially on those tricky breaking putts where an early skid can throw everything off.
The Toe Hang That Actually Makes Sense
Here's where the engineering gets interesting (and where I had to eat some humble pie). I've always been suspicious of putters that try to be everything to everyone. The Mullen has a slight toe hang – not the aggressive toe hang of a classic blade, but enough to complement a natural toe release through impact. For years, I thought toe hang was toe hang, period. But TaylorMade has found this sweet spot that works for both moderate arc strokes and those of us who have just a hint of rotation.
I spent an afternoon at the practice green experimenting with different stroke paths. With my natural slight arc, the putter wanted to square up at exactly the right moment. It wasn't fighting me like face-balanced mallets tend to do, but it also wasn't so toe-heavy that I had to consciously manipulate it. The double-bend shaft option on the Mullen 2 gives you a face-balanced alternative if you're a straight-back-straight-through player, but honestly, the original slight toe hang works for more stroke types than TaylorMade probably even intended.
The two 5-gram weights in the sole aren't just for show either. They lower the center of gravity and increase the MOI without making the head feel like a sledgehammer. I removed them temporarily (yes, I'm that guy who takes things apart), and the difference in stability on off-center hits was immediately noticeable. With the weights installed, heel and toe strikes still find their way to the hole with surprising regularity.
Alignment Features That Don't Overcomplicate Things
I've tested putters with so many alignment aids that they look like airport runways. The Mullen keeps it simple with two sightlines on the back cavity, and honestly, that's all you need. These lines frame the ball perfectly at the address without creating visual noise. They're milled into the stainless steel, not painted on, so they won't wear off after a season of use (looking at you, cheaper putters with painted alignment aids).
What I really appreciate is how these sightlines work with the comprehensive shape of the putter. The compact mallet design means you can still see enough of the face to confirm you're square, while the lines give you a clear path visualization. I've found myself making more confident strokes, especially on those vital four-to-six footers where alignment is everything. The two-line alignment system delivers exactly what TaylorMade intended: a clean visual reference that enhances accuracy without cluttering your view at address.
Setting up for the ball feels intuitive. There's no guesswork about where to position your eyes or how to orient the putter. After about three rounds, I stopped consciously thinking about alignment; it just happened naturally. That's when you know the design is working.
Build Quality That Justifies the Premium Price
Let's talk about what you're actually getting for your money. The 303 stainless steel isn't just marketing speak; it's a premium material that's precision-milled to tolerances that would make a Swiss watchmaker jealous. The entire putter is machine-crafted and then skim-milled for that perfect feel and sound at impact. When you tap a ball, you get this satisfying "tock" that's neither too loud nor too muted.
I've put this putter through about 40 rounds now, plus countless practice sessions, and it still looks virtually new. The finish holds up extraordinarily well, no dings, no scratches that catch your eye at address, no worn spots where your hands grip. Compare that to some of the insert putters I've tested that start showing wear after a month, and the value proposition becomes clearer.
The weight distribution feels purposeful throughout the entire club. At 350 grams, it's not the heaviest putter I've tested, but it has this substantial feel that breeds confidence. The balance point is exactly where it should be, making it easy to control tempo without feeling like you're swinging a pendulum. Even the grip (which I usually replace immediately) is high-quality and properly sized for the head weight.
Performance Where It Counts Most
After extensive testing, I tracked my putting stats for 20 rounds with my old blade versus 20 rounds with the Mullen. The results? My putts per round dropped from 31.2 to 29.8. More importantly, my make percentage from 4-8 feet jumped from 62% to 71%. Those are the putts that make or break your score, and the Mullen delivers where it matters most.
The combination of the Pure Roll insert technology and the improved stability from the sole weights creates a larger sweet spot than any blade I've used. Miss-hits that would normally come up short are reaching the hole. Putts that I'd usually pull under pressure are holding their line. It's not magic, it's just good engineering doing what it's supposed to do.
Distance control has been the biggest revelation. On lag putts from 20+ feet, I'm consistently leaving myself inside three feet for the comebacker. The immediate forward roll from the Pure Roll insert takes so much guesswork out of judging pace, especially on slower greens where you really need to give it a rap.
TaylorMade TP Mullen Putter Review
TaylorMade TP Mullen Putter delivers buttery-soft feel and elite consistency on every putt.
Is the TaylorMade TP Mullen Putter Worth It?
Absolutely, while the TaylorMade TP Mullen Putter is a great product, there are a few pros and cons that you need to be aware of:
Pros:
Pure Roll insert technology genuinely improves roll and distance control
Perfect balance of blade feel with mallet stability and forgiveness
Premium 303 stainless steel construction that will last for years
Cons:
Premium price point might be steep for weekend warriors
Slight toe hang won't suit extremely straight-back-straight-through strokes
Compact mallet shape might not inspire confidence for players who prefer larger heads
Frequently Asked Questions
Is the Taylormade TP Mullen Putter Available for Left-Handed Golfers?
Yes, you can definitely get the TaylorMade TP Mullen putter in left-handed configurations. You'll find the TP Black Copper Mullen 2 available for lefties at multiple retailers including 2nd Swing and Mr. Topes Golf. They're offered in different lengths from 33 to 36 inches with steel shafts. You'll see prices ranging from $149.99 to $185.00 for new left-handed models, which is discounted from the original $200 retail price.
What Is the Warranty Period for the TP Mullen Putter?
Your TP Mullen putter comes with TaylorMade's standard 2-year warranty from your original purchase date. Since it's a post-2006 product, it doesn't qualify for the extended 5-year coverage that older models receive. You'll need to keep your receipt from an authorized retailer as proof of purchase. The warranty covers defects in materials and workmanship under normal use, but won't cover normal wear, abuse, or any aftermarket modifications you make.
Can the Grip Be Customized or Replaced With Aftermarket Options?
Yes, you can easily replace the grip with aftermarket options. Your TP Mullen comes with a SuperStroke Pistol 1.0 grip that's replaceable like any standard putter grip. You'll find no restrictions on grip modifications, and the double-bend shaft supports standard grip attachment. You can swap it for Golf Honor, Lamkin, or other aftermarket grips without affecting performance or voiding warranty. Many users successfully replace grips when the original wears out.
Where Is the Taylormade TP Mullen Putter Manufactured?
Your TaylorMade TP Mullen putter is manufactured in China at the company's primary production facility. While the design and engineering happen in the United States, the actual manufacturing takes place in China where they produce all drivers, irons, and putters. This setup combines American innovation with Chinese manufacturing proficiency, utilizing advanced technologies and skilled labor to achieve the 100% precision required for the machine-milled 303 stainless steel construction.
Does Taylormade Offer a Trade-In Program for This Putter Model?
Yes, you can trade in your TP Mullen putter through TaylorMade's Official Trade-In Program. The TP Collection Mullen SuperStroke is specifically listed for trade-in valuation on their site. You'll add new clubs to your cart, select your putter from the dropdown menu, ship it with their label, and receive credit within 15 business days. Third-party options like 2nd Swing, GlobalGolf, and GolfBlueBook also accept this model for trade-in credit.
Final Thoughts
The TaylorMade TP Mullen isn't going to reshape a bad putter into a good one overnight. But if you're a decent putter looking for that extra edge, or someone curious about mallets but put off by their typically clunky appearance, this deserves serious consideration. It's particularly well-suited for players with a slight arc in their stroke who want more forgiveness than a blade offers without sacrificing feel.
At the end of the day, this putter made a blade devotee reconsider everything I thought I knew about mallets. It's now earned a permanent spot in my bag, and considering how stubborn I am about equipment changes, that's saying something. If you're on the fence, find a way to roll a few putts with one. The combination of creative insert technology, thoughtful design, and premium construction makes this one of the best putters TaylorMade has produced in years.
Paul Liberatore
As the Founder of Golfers Authority Paul Liberatore Esq. has spent the last 7+ years writing about the best golf equipment or instruction from the top golf instructors in the world. He has been a contributing writer for Sports Illustrated Golf and GolfWRX. After graduating with honors from Purdue University, he realized that he had a passion for the golf business and the law. When he's not practicing law, or creating golf content on YouTube, he can be found on his syndicated Behind the Golf Brand podcast talking with the most prolific leaders in the golf industry.
